One by one
What each option is good at, and what it costs you
Every paragraph below lists both. A comparison that only lists the first half is the most common kind of dishonest comparison page.
Tailscale
The best-polished clients, with the control plane hosted abroad
Good at: a WireGuard-based mesh with carefully built clients on every platform, MagicDNS, and identity through Google, Microsoft or GitHub, plus strong SSO and ACL expressiveness.
You accept: the free Personal tier is non-commercial only, so a company network must pay; billing is per seat, so headcount drives cost; and when hole punching fails, traffic falls back to vendor DERP relays, whose latency and throughput are outside your control.
ZeroTier
The most generous free tier, on a non-WireGuard protocol
Good at: 10 free devices, the friendliest of the group for many machines and few people; a layer-2 style network that suits broadcast and discovery protocols; mature clients including NAS and router firmware.
You accept: its own protocol rather than WireGuard, so performance and audit are separate from the WireGuard ecosystem; the free tier allows one network and one admin, which teams outgrow quickly; and a self-hosted controller means giving up vendor-side management and support.
Pgy (Oray)
The easiest domestic procurement, with data on the vendor side
Good at: multi-line BGP relay inside China, stable on weak networks; hardware routers and boxes, which suits stores that have no server at all; complete invoicing and support processes, so there is someone to call.
You accept: no free tier is listed on the pricing page, with the entry plan at ¥148 per licensed device per year; the control plane belongs to the vendor, so topology and policy are not yours; audit retention depends on tier (30 / 90 / 180 days).
Headscale
Free and fully yours, if you are the operations team
Good at: an open-source implementation of the Tailscale control server that works with the official clients, with no user cap. The cost is one server.
You accept: no official web console, so day-to-day work is command line and config files; upgrades, backups and incident response are yours; and its feature scope is narrower than the hosted product.
VirtuaMesh
Self-hosted and productised, but you need a server
Good at: control plane and DERP both run on your own server, so topology and policy never leave your rack; a graphical console with RBAC, tiered ACL and audit logs built in rather than assembled; Chinese-language UI and domestic network conditions as a design premise.
What it will not do: it needs a server, so "zero deployment" users are not a fit; the free tier is 5 nodes, fewer than ZeroTier's 10 devices; client polish and third-party integrations are behind Tailscale; and we publish no benchmark numbers — the next section tells you how to measure it yourself, which is worth more than a millisecond figure of unknown origin.
Price
Why per-unit prices cannot be compared directly
A Pgy licence includes their relay servers and bandwidth. Ours does not include your server. Put those two numbers side by side and the conclusion will be wrong. So here is a three-year total, with both deployment paths listed separately.
| Three-year cost | Pgy Commercial (5 licensed devices) | VirtuaMesh Standard (spare machine) | VirtuaMesh Standard (cloud host) |
|---|
| Nodes / licences | 5 client licences (= 5 devices; hardware licence ¥328/yr each) | 15 nodes | 15 nodes |
| Licence / subscription | ¥148 × 5 × 3 = ¥2,220 | 3-year contract ¥993 (¥399/yr × 3, 8.3折) | same, ¥993 |
| Server | Not required, included | ¥0 (existing machine) | ≈ ¥600/yr × 3 = ¥1,800 |
| Relay bandwidth | 8Mbps per licensed device, included; expandable | Depends on your machine and line | Cloud host bandwidth |
| Operations | Vendor | Self-service (about half a day to deploy) | Self-service (about half a day to deploy) |
| Three-year total | ¥2,220 | ¥993 | ¥2,793 |
Half the price without labour, the same ballpark once you add itThe figures above leave no allowance for labour or extra bandwidth. At ¥200/hour (half a day to deploy plus two hours a year), self-hosting adds roughly ¥1,400–2,000 over three years: about ¥2,400–3,000 on a spare machine, ¥4,200–4,800 on a cloud host.
Per node the gap is clearer: Pgy works out at ¥2,220 / 5 ≈ ¥444 per device over three years (including their relay bandwidth and lines); ours is ¥993 / 15 ≈ ¥66 per node (excluding your server and operations). The larger the scale, the wider the gap.
In other words: how much you save depends on whether you already have a machine and someone who can look after it. With a spare machine and in-house hands, three years costs about half of Pgy's total; with only a cloud host and labour costed in, the two land in the same range (¥2,400–3,000 against ¥2,220). We would not lead with "cheaper" — what you actually buy is the next section.
Prices captured from vendor pricing pages on 17 Nov 2026. Pgy is costed at its published annual price, without any multi-year discount it may offer; VirtuaMesh uses our published 3-year contract price (8.3 of 10). Cloud host estimated at a 2 vCPU / 2GB entry configuration, bandwidth costed at 5Mbps. The labour estimate is illustrative only — your hourly rate sets the real number.